Maîtres mots

  • Il y a longtemps que notre pays est beau mais rude.

       --Newspaper editor Olivier Séguret, 25 January 2012

    The USA are entirely the creation of the accursed race, the French.

       --Evelyn Waugh (1903-1966), writing to Nancy Mitford, 22 May 1957

Search Rue Rude with Google

French Freedom of Speech

Today the cheminots are:

  • "À nous de vous faire préférer le train!"
    "Voyager autrement"
    "Avec le SNCF, tout est possible"
      --Former ad slogans of the SNCF (French national trains), each in turn quickly dropped

Fun French words

  • social

    (Warning: the French word social is a faux ami, or false friend. It does not mean "social" in English. It is used mainly to refer to union activity, public protests, or government programs. A plan social means mass layoffs.)

    Air France veut un accord avant janvier pour éviter le plan social.

Who's en colère today?

Go back to school in Paris!

Send to StumbleUpon!

Become a Fan

Subscribe to Rue Rude's feed

« Christmas tips | Main | The Disneyland Parade; Christmas parties in Paris »


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Fascinating article!

Wow, thank you so much for that, I really enjoyed it! :)

Prezado Editor

Lendo seu comentário a respeito de Henri Charrière, quero respeitosamente informá-lo que já foi comprovado que Henri Charrière foi o maior farsante da literatura mundial.
Foram 15 anos investigando esse caso!

Foram realizadas quatro pericias a mais recente a dos Peritos Federais Brasileiros considerados os melhores de todo o planeta! Verdades que eles fizeram questão de divulgar em seu site, com este titulo: - PERITO DA POLICIA FEDERAL ENCONTRA EM RORAIMA O VERDADEIRO PAPILLON



Platão Arantes
Jornalista registro profissional 1.093 FENAJ
0xx (95) 81129898

My inexpert translation of the previous comment:

Dear Editor,

Reading your commentary with respect to Henri Charrière, I would like respectfully to inform you that it has already been proven that Henri Charrière was the greatest joker in world literature. I have been investigating this case for 15 years!

There have been four experts, the most recent being the Peritos Federais Brasileiros, considered the best on the whole planet! Truths that they insist on divulging on their site: Experts of the Federal Police coming across Roraima, or, the real Papillon:

El Dorado: The big lie of Henri Charrière

Blog Papillon

Platão Arantes
Registered professional journalist 1.093 FENAJ
0xx (95) 81129898

Excellent book but I did think he portrayed himself as a bit of a superhero. Now I know why - pure fantasy !!!!

in my opinion it doesn't matter if the book is pure fantasy or fiction, what matters is the effect it has on you. Papillon is an inspirational book which encourages hope and will, whatever the circumstances. Who cares if the stories are actually a collection of experiences of many people. Most of us will never experience anything of that calibre anyway. A second-hand account is more realistic than a fantasy, at least someone lived through it to tell the tale.

Irrespective of Henri Charrier's (Papillon)possible fantasy, the fact of the matter is, he indeed, alongside other prisoners of the penal colony suffered inhuman treatment at the hand's of a brutal regime; he was confined to solitary and he did many prisoners did not survive? Henri Charrier was without question a very, very tough human being, who deserves credit alone for his survival of a barbaric and despicable French legal system.


Papillon was without question a very durable person who had special vitalities that deserved him the recognition of a survivor.

QUOTE: 'Papillon is an inspirational book which encourages hope and will, whatever the circumstances'


Acompanhem os fascinantes debates sobre as teorias do livro de Platão no blog da deputada Surita, confiram : ( This post is a link to interesting discussions in a blog of a Brazilian deputy, where it was proven that the journalist Platão Arantes was totally wrong trying to discredit Charrière )

Aslında iki kitabı da okuyanlar kitaplar arasında bazı noktalarda uyuşmazlıklar olduğunu fark edecektirler. Mesela "Kelebek" kitabının sonlarında artık intikamından tamamen vazgeçtiğinden bahsederken "Banko" kitabının henüz başında sanki hiç böyle bir şey olmamış gibi anlatıyor. Ayrıca ilk kitapta çok önemli ve yer kaplayan bölümlerden olan kızılderililerle yaşadığı dönemden ikinci kitapta hiç bahsedilmiyor.Halbuki Kızılderili eşine tekrar döneceğine dair söz vermişti ve bunun için uğraşmadı bile. Tabii ki insan anlatılanların doğru olduğuna inanmak istiyor. I have written this paragraph in turkish. my english is enough to read this news but isn't enough to write my comments :)

I used Google Translate to understand a bit of what you wrote! It gave me this (I changed the phrasing to make it more English but it doesn't completely translate it correctly):

"In fact, some of the points in dispute between the two books will be realized by those who read the books. For example, in "Papillon" vengeance is now completely surrendered at the end of the book; talking about the "Reception" at the beginning of the book, it says no such thing has happened. Also very important, in the first book in the sections covering the period of his second book there is no mention of the Indians. However, the Indians promised his wife would return to [him?] again and [he?] even did not bother to do this. Of course people want to believe that the accounts are true."

Let me know if this is what you mean?

Thanks for writing in!

I am from India ( in Asia, not from the Indian guajira tribes Papi came across in the book). I recently read the book, and am quite enthralled by it. So much that, i started finding more information on Papillon, which is how i stumbled across this website. Whether Henri is not the real Papillon does not matter, what matters is the way the book has been written and the effect it has on you. Hats off to Papi!!

this book inspired me to become, as the author puts it:"a man equal to himself.(myself)." regardless of who did the actual deeds, i am impressed with the book, the man, the historical context, and most of all what i have gained from it.

The fact is even if this guy is lying its not hard to believe that this whole scenario is either true,or very close to the truth for someone somewhere in the world. It will always be a great story of man's endurance and capacity to withstand any amount of suffering. Never give up and you have a chance no matter how small it may seem!

I am from India(Asia). It's one of the best inspirational books of our lifetime. Who cares it's fiction or biographical. Book makes you laugh think and mores than that gives you a positive energy. What more do you need from a book.

As an Astrologer it is interesting to note that C Brunier was born in the sign of Gemini...

I had never read that H Charriere said the story was true to 75%. What he said it was all true apart from some minor memoryloss.

Continuing...H Charriere had both Sun and Moon in Scorpio. That tells people who are in to Astrology that this man lives trough his feelings. He even speaks about this in Papillon or Banco. It took several years of persuation from Rita and other people before he even started writing about his escapes and adventures. One special event in Papillon (the book) is when he want to take care of the funeral himself of a dead friend in the sea. He puts heavy changes of metal around the body so that the sharks wont start eating the body at the surface.

But that did not work and the sharks got hold of the body and swam around with it. This is mentioned by C H and he says that his friend where waving goodbye with one of his arms carried around with the shark under the surface. Now, I am not experts on shark but I think they move like this when they are eating. It is likely that this has occured. If you can understand this then the rest of the book is not so hard to believe. Its a fantastic story yes. But why do people say he is lying. Maybe they have boring lives. No passion, no drama. H C was full of that , and of loving to be free..

Live a life in danger and imprisonment for 13 years and its bound to happen many things. This prisons at those times is not the same prisons as are present now. Hence the many escapes.

A question? Is it bragging when he admits jumping from 8 meters and breaking both feets. No! Its the search for escape, the will for being free.

In 2005 in comes this C Brunier and claims he is the real Papillon at age 104. Silly talk.

My wish is they made a new movie following the book better. This escape in the movie when they are running in the jungle and one prisoner is impaled in the gut is not in the book for example. A new movie would be a blockbuster. Then raise a statue in honour of Charriere in Aubenas.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Today's quotation

  • Soon you will have forgotten the world, and soon the world will have forgotten you.

      --Roman emperor Marcus Aurelius (121-180) in his Meditations (Book Seven)

Le petit aperçu d'Ailleurs

  • Six employees of Air France have been arrested after violence last week against two human resources managers who had the unpleasant task of announcing that 2500+ jobs would be lost. Politicians Jean-Luc Mélenchon (Party of the Left), Cécile Duflot (ex-Ecology Minister), and Pierre Laurent (French Communist Party) immediately denounced the arrests. "What a day of mourning! Four employees arrested for 'an act of struggle'," said Mélenchon. His party said that it was "ashamed of this administration, which continues to criminalize union activity."

News about France in English

Nice to Rude

In Paris, alone, need help?

Overblogs (blogs of blogs)

Paris France in English

Paris en photo